CIRCULATING CURRENTS
TESTING AND ADJUSTING
to correctly distribute magnetizing current and keep the
circulating currents to a minimum. Example:
Load kW 700, Load Line Amperes 1,100,
Voltage 460
Generator No. 1, Load kW 250,
Line Amperes 500
Generator No. 2, Load kW 450,
Line Amperes 630
It should be obvious that the voltage level setting on
Generator No. 2 is too low. Adjustments could be made
to one or both until No. 1 shows a line ampere reading
of about 390, and the line ampere reading of No. 2
shows about 700 amperes. At these conditions, both
generators will be operating at the same load power
factor of 0.8. Circulating current is at a minimum.
Refinements as described above will assure highly
satisfactory operation of paralleled generator sets.
Summary
Circulating currents exist in paralleled generators when
the several generators are attempting to operate at
different voltages although they are connected together
through the common bus. These circulating currents
reduce
the
effective
excitation
of
one
or
more
generators, and increase the effective excitation of
others. Generator voltage is directly related to exciter
output. Hence, an attempted generator voltage
difference is the result of different exciter output. Exciter
output is controlled by the voltage regulator, and ultimate
control of circulating current is a function of the regulator.
Effect of Circulating Currents
On Load Sensing Electronic Governors
The Woodward 2301 load sensing governor can react to
excessively large circulating currents. With correct
adjustment of generator voltage regulators, the load
sensing governor responds to true power or kW load on
the generator set. However, when the value of
circulating current between generators approaches the
value of the actual load current, the governors may react
to these excessive circulating currents and change the
kW load division between generator sets. Load transfer
may be slow, or it may be rapid. There is no predictable
pattern since the observed action depends on the
condition of the generator voltage regulators controlling
the several generators.
Incorrectly adjusted voltage regulators are the most
common cause of the "load shift" problem. It is generally
found that initial generator regulator adjustments fail to
include
adequate
voltage
droop
or
cross-current
compensation. This difficulty can also cause operating
errors.
Some commercially available generator control panels
for use with commercially avail-able generators include a
switch that bypasses the voltage droop circuit in the
voltage regulator. These switches have various names
such as "Single-Parallel" or "Droop In Droop Out."
Operators incorrectly position these switches during
parallel operation, causing one or more generators to
operate
without
voltage
droop
or
cross-current
compensation. Circulating currents can greatly increase
under these conditions. Governors will generally react.
Switchboard wiring errors, such as reverse-connected
current transformers (used as part of the droop or cross-
current system), can also cause load shift problems. In
these instances, the voltage droop system causes a rise
in generated voltage as the line current increases.
Circulating currents can increase rapidly, and possibly
cause circuit breakers to open. Governor reaction may
be noted just prior to circuit breaker opening.
125